Have you seen this photo?
Talk about being in the right place at the right time. On Monday, Stefanie Gordon snapped the pic while flying on Delta from NYC to Palm Beach, and when she landed she posted the picture to Twitter. The result? As of the time of writing this post, this TwitPic has viewed more than 450,000 views, and Stefanie has quadrupled her Twitter followers.
I don’t want to get into the legal analysis of the use of this picture. Our laws and contracts that govern these uses are a reflection of the culture at the particular time. My question is what time are we in? This issue is occurring at the intersection of two paradigms: mainstream media and social media revolution.
In one time, images or user generated content have rights and are compensatory, and in the other they are free, sharable, and the rights function on the honor system.
The value of the content in the mainstream media paradigm has traditionally been increased by scarcity. Networks invest heavily to have an exclusive story, which increases the audience for the network. Increased share of the audience translates into increased advertising revenue.
The value of the content in social media is increased by ubiquity. When a user creates interesting “share-worthy” content, they are “compensated” by their networks with shares, likes, retweets, comments. This economy of generosity catapults unknown people onto a connected stage. For example, Antoine Dodson was propelled into national spotlight with more than 80 million views thanks to the Gregory brothers, and the bed intruder song instantly became a meme with hundreds of variations (including my favorite).
Like two ships passing in the night, MSM and social have incompatible values. Language of copyright, compensation, ownership are not the tender in the world of social. Regardless of the compensation or “legally compliant use,” attribution and conversation is the standard of currency in this economy. The beauty of this paradigm, however, is that means by the one-to-many MSM to circumvent attribution leads to many-to-many conversation through blogging, tweeting, and communicating with friends.